WE’RE AVAILABLE 24/7

Is a Verbal Agreement to an Insurance Settlement Binding in Texas?

insurance claim form paper

A verbal agreement to an insurance settlement can be legally binding in Texas, even when it is made over the phone and never put in writing, as long as the conversation includes an offer, an acceptance, and benefits for both sides.

Often, many insurance adjusters’ tactic after a car accident is to immediately call their opposition, using the conversation to then manipulate them into an agreement that will likely leave the injured person with an awful settlement. There is nothing in Texas law that states an agreement has to go further than a simple conversation for it to become legally binding. Furthermore, it’s also completely legal for the insurance company to record any phone communication without first asking for the permission of all parties involved.

This combination of loopholes in Texas law means that this tactic has become an unfortunately common practice which insurance companies can use to doom their opposition’s case. By legal definition, a verbal agreement becomes binding in Texas if three stages of the agreement are found to be present in the conversation. Essentially, if the dialogue contains some form of offer, a statement of acceptance, and has also discussed reasonable benefits for each side of the case, the verbal agreement becomes binding.

KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Verbal agreements can be legally binding in Texas if they include an offer, acceptance, and mutual benefits for both parties. Insurance companies often use recorded phone calls to create binding agreements that could hurt your case.
  • Never accept an insurance settlement offer quickly, especially after a serious accident. Insurance adjusters are trained to manipulate your words and minimize your claim.
  • Always consult with an attorney before accepting any settlement. An attorney will protect your rights and ensure that any agreement made is fair and in your best interest.

What Makes a Verbal Agreement Legally Binding in Texas?

When an injured person disputes a verbal settlement, Texas courts look at whether there was a meeting of the minds as to the terms of the settlement agreement. A recorded phone call can show that meeting of the minds when the conversation includes:

  • Some form of offer, such as a set payment in exchange for releasing the injury claim.
  • A statement of acceptance from the person receiving the offer.
  • Reasonable benefits for each side of the case.

In Windell Gilbert v. Cherish Fitz, a Dallas County case, the adjuster later told the injured man’s law firm that his bodily injury claim had been settled and that a verbal release was on file.

Avoiding the Trap of Verbal Agreements

Never accept any offer for a settlement quickly — in situations where there has been a serious car wreck, financial aid towards medical treatment will be needed after the incident has occurred.

Example Case: $500 Verbal Settlement on a Recorded Call

In the past, insurance adjusters have exploited quick settlement offers in cases such as Windell Gilbert v. Cherish Fitz. Mr. Gilbert received financial aid towards healthcare for only the day of the incident, yet his injuries persisted further and his opponent’s insurance company was not legally obliged to compensate. This was because the adjusters had called on the day of the incident and offered Mr. Gilbert the coverage for the day of the incident as well as $500. Because the call was recorded with Mr. Gilbert’s permission while he accepted this offer, Cherish Fitz’s insurer, GEICO, managed to prove the existence of a verbal contract, and no further reimbursement was made.

How Should You Handle Insurance Adjuster Calls?

If you are contacted by an insurance company or an insurance adjuster after a car accident, it is imperative to avoid speaking to them alone. Exercise your rights and demand to only speak to them once you are accompanied by an automobile collision lawyer in West Houston. Having an attorney present will allow protection from any manipulative tactics by the adjuster such as those mentioned above — even if they seem to want to help, the fact they can record your conversation without your knowledge is legally dangerous.

SLF White Background logo

If you’ve been hurt in an accident, you’re probably feeling overwhelmed and unsure where to turn. Joe Stephens is here to listen, guide you, and fight for the full compensation you need to move forward with your life.

Case Study: $325,000 Insurance Settlement After a $12,000 Offer

A client suffered a herniated disc in his neck after a car wreck and required surgery. Although the at-fault driver carried only a $30,000 policy, insurer Fred Loya refused to pay even the limits, initially offering just $12,000. Attorney Joe Stephens filed suit and continued increasing demands as the case progressed. On the eve of trial, Fred Loya replaced its legal team, and the new attorney convinced the carrier to offer $325,000. The client ultimately accepted the settlement, more than 10 times the original policy limit, as listed in the firm’s case results.

Call an Experienced Car Accident Lawyer in West Houston

If you or someone you know has been in a car crash contact a top rated West Houston commercial truck accident lawyer. With extensive experience dealing with automobile collisions, West Houston lawyer Joe Stephens will listen and understand on a deeper level the causes behind your accident.

Our law firm specializes in a variety of different collision/crash cases, and can also help with issues or queries involving insurance and its intricacies. We make sure you feel heard and understood. Equally important to us as the liability is the potential compensation you deserve.

If you’re experiencing distrust or problems sorting a settlement out with the insurance companies of involved parties, turn to us for a hand — we’d love to help.

Related Posts
Free Case Evaluation
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Consent(Required)